Software companies' "smokescreen" complaint investigation against Education Software Solutions dropped by CMA

For more than a decade ESS has provided a safe and authorised method to transfer data from SIMS through the SIMS Application Programming Interfaces ("APIs").  The APIs preserve the integrity of data extracted from SIMS and are widely used with over 5 billion API calls being made in an average month.  Given the availability of these APIs there is no justification for ESS' competitors copying SIMS databases or inducing ESS' customers to do so on their behalf.  ESS was and is entitled to object to the unlawful use of its intellectual property and to take action against anyone infringing its intellectual property rights.

ESS wrote to certain competitors and schools in December 2023 objecting to the unsafe and unlawful use of SIMS databases to undertake data transfers, reminding them that the APIs and the SIMS Report Generator are the only safe and ESS authorised means for extracting data from SIMS.  In response a number of these competitor complained to the CMA, which began its investigation.   Six months on, that investigation has been closed, with the CMA acknowledging that (as ESS had said all along) the APIs provide an entirely proper, and in the CMA's words, 'less burdensome' and 'less error prone' method of data extraction than the use of copies of the SIMS database.

Commenting on this decision, Lewis Alcraft, Group Chief Executive of ESS said:

"Certain of our competitors complained to the CMA that the SIMS APIs were too 'complex, time consuming and error prone' to be usable.  That this was untrue is now evident from the fact that these same competitors are now using, or proposing to use, these APIs to undertake migrations, a method which in the words of the CMA is 'less burdensome' and 'less error prone' than using copies of the SIMS database. We hope that everyone now sees that these complaints were a smokescreen for the continued unlawful use of ESS' intellectual property."

ESS is considering what action should be taken regarding any misuse of its intellectual property now that the CMA's investigation has been closed. ESS has no wish to impede schools from switching to alternative suppliers provided this is done lawfully.  To that end, ESS calls upon any school that intends to transfer data to a new supplier not to be persuaded into handing over backup copies of the SIMS database as part of this exercise, noting that to do so would be a breach of the school's licensing agreement with ESS.  Schools should instead insist that any new supplier uses the SIMS APIs. 

View original content:https://www.prnewswire.co.uk/news-releases/software-companies-smokescreen-complaint-investigation-against-education-software-solutions-dropped-by-cma-302234159.html